MISO and NYISO propose $100 and $200/MWh cutoffs for non-firm large loads
Both answered FERC's large-load orders on November 16, 2026: MISO aims for five-month studies and 20-year cost commitments, while New York's studies run up to two years and its utilities would recover upgrade costs over 15.
Three grid operators have now named three different prices at which flexible data centers and other large loads get cut off. In filings at the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission on November 16, 2026, the Midcontinent ISO proposed a Grid Responsive Integration Transmission Service (GRITS) whose non-firm portion is interrupted whenever the local price exceeds $100/MWh (GRITS filing), and the New York ISO proposed a Non-Firm Withdrawal Service with a mandatory $200/MWh bid cap (NYISO filing). ISO New England, which filed three days earlier, set its trigger at $250/MWh.
For a data center developer, MISO's package means one required study for every large-load request, service options that include firm service and interim non-firm service that can step up to firm in pieces, plus cost recovery agreements signed not by the data center but by its transmission customer, commonly the load-serving utility. New York's adds a study queue of its own, two new withdrawal services and, from its utilities, a cost recovery agreement signed by the large load itself or its agent. Both answer FERC's June 18 show-cause orders: MISO (ER27-526) asks for a February 14, 2027 effective date, NYISO (ER27-517) for February 1, 2027, New York's six traditional transmission owners filed the cost-recovery half separately (ER27-529), and the California ISO filed its own rules the same day, approved by its board in October.
Who studies, and how fast
MISO is selling speed. Its Large Load Project Review is designed to take about five months, runs three times a year, and has a first application deadline of March 1, 2027. Only the transmission customer, commonly the load-serving utility, can apply, and it pays a non-refundable $250,000 application fee plus a $100,000 study deposit; the requested service and megawatts cannot change once the application is in.
New York is slower and says so. Its study cycle runs from about 18 months to two years, including a 90-day system impact study, and NYISO "acknowledges that the proposed timeframe is longer than the process duration contemplated by the Show Cause Order," which floated 60 to 90 days. The entry fee is $10,000, with first study deposits of $100,000 to $200,000 by project size in a regular cycle. MISO's fee is 25 times New York's, by our arithmetic, though New York asks for more later: a project entering the full assessment posts a readiness deposit of $4,000 per MW, $2 million for a 500 MW campus by our arithmetic. The first transition cycle would start June 1, 2027, and New York's utilities do not expect the first large loads to finish facilities studies until the third quarter of 2028.
California's utilities run the studies, which CAISO expects them to complete within 60 to 90 days, with CAISO reviewing them monthly. PJM's Fast Energization proposal sits between MISO's roughly five months and New York's 18 months to two years, studying loads and generators together in 12 months.
Who pays for the wires
Both plans are designed to keep upgrade costs off other customers, but they bill different parties. MISO's agreements bind the transmission customer, commonly the load-serving utility, and leave states free to require agreements with the data centers behind it. Where a MISO utility rolls the upgrades into its rates, the transmission customer owes a revenue commitment covering their capital cost, return, depreciation, maintenance and taxes over 20 years. Each year its transmission charges are compared against that commitment and any shortfall comes due as a Supplemental Payment: MISO's example is a $10 million commitment against $7 million in revenue, leaving a $3 million bill. Utilities may instead assign the costs directly, and either way the transmission customer remains responsible, MISO says. Security equal to the upgrades' capital cost, such as a letter of credit, surety bond or parent guaranty, is due within 45 days of signing.
New York's transmission owners want the load's side on the hook, and faster. Their agreements are signed with the Large Load Customer, the load or an agent acting for it, rather than an energy service company or other intermediary, and it posts the security directly. The cost recovery agreement recovers 100% of a large load's allocated upgrade costs through a formula rate used only for large-load customers, compressed into 15 years without accelerated depreciation. Many upgrades last 40 years or longer, they note, and a contract that long "increases performance and financial security/collateral risks that can result in stranded costs and cost shifts to other customers." Security is cash or a letter of credit, sized from the facilities study estimates.
California leaves deposits, security and cost recovery to its utilities' own tariffs, the split the state's Public Advocates Office challenged before the board vote.
Firm, non-firm and the capacity question
The flexibility designs differ more than the prices. GRITS lets a customer split one load into firm and non-firm parts, 200 MW firm and 300 MW non-firm on a 500 MW load in MISO's example. MISO says historical data, including the 2025 State of the Market report, show the $100 cap permits service in more than 95% of hours, and that the cap sits at the first non-zero step of its short-term reserve demand curve so non-firm load is offline before reserves run short. The service arrives without a price, though: GRITS rates are left to a later filing, and MISO says the earliest it can run GRITS is January 1, 2029.
Until then MISO offers Interim NITS, non-firm service for a load waiting on its upgrades. It can be curtailed whenever transmission conditions require; in a transmission emergency it goes after non-firm point-to-point service and before firm service, and it is never curtailed solely to relieve economic congestion. It also stays inside MISO's capacity requirements, which MISO says keeps interim status from operating "as a capacity exemption." A companion Firm Service Step Up converts pieces of it to firm service as upgrades finish.
New York ties firmness to resource adequacy instead. A project gets its full request as Firm Withdrawal Service only if it degrades resource adequacy by 25 MW or less; beyond that, part of it becomes non-firm until loss-of-load expectation returns to its pre-project level. NYISO points to statewide resource deficiencies it has identified beginning in 2033. The exception is a State Exempt Large Load Project, identified by the state's Department of Public Service: those projects are judged as a group against New York's reliability criterion for the first five study years, a compromise NYISO says reconciles its reliability duties with the Public Service Commission's authority over resource adequacy.
Outlook
Comments on NYISO's filing are due December 7 under FERC's notice, though NYISO asked for 28 days instead of the standard 21; MISO and CAISO each asked for 30. The Southwest Power Pool's deadline is November 20, 2026, set in FERC's August 14 order which recorded an SPP board vote scheduled for November 17. If FERC accepts the filings as proposed, MISO's study process would open before New York's, while price-triggered non-firm service would wait for MISO's 2029 software and New York's June 1, 2028 market rules.
⚠ The Outlook extrapolates from the comment date in FERC's November 16, 2026 combined notice, the comment periods MISO, NYISO and CAISO requested, FERC's August 14, 2026 SPP abeyance order, and the effective and implementation dates MISO and NYISO requested in their filings.
Sources
Primary
- Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc., Large Load Review, Cost Recovery and Transmission Services Filing, Docket No. ER27-526-000 · MISO (filed with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission)
Supporting
- Letter order granting abeyance, Southwest Power Pool, Inc. et al., Docket No. EL26-68-000 (196 FERC ¶ 61,128) · Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
- New York Independent System Operator, Inc., Proposed Tariff Revisions to Establish New Large Load Integration Procedures and Related Market Participation Provisions, Docket No. ER27-517-000 · NYISO (filed with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission)
- California Independent System Operator Corporation, Large Loads Tariff Amendment, Response to Order to Show Cause, Docket No. ER27-532-000 · California ISO (filed with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission)
- FERC, Combined Notice of Filings #1, November 16, 2026 · Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
- New York Transmission Owners, Section 205 Filing in Response to the Large Load Show Cause Order, Docket No. ER27-529-000 · New York Transmission Owners (filed by NYISO with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission)
- Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc., Grid Responsive Integration Transmission Service Filing, Docket No. ER27-527-000 · MISO (filed with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission)
Copies of cited sources are retained where available. If a link no longer resolves, request a copy at contact@theduckcurve.com.