New York staff back 5 GW nuclear goal and open-book reactor deals
Ratepayers would pay mainly once reactors run, though not wholly clear of construction risk; state equity, overrun cover and early grants each need funding first. The white paper came with the state's 30-point nuclear master plan.
New York's Department of Public Service staff recommended on November 18, 2026 that the Public Service Commission adopt an 8.4 GW "Nuclear Reliability Backbone" with a target of 5 GW of new advanced nuclear generation, and direct the department and NYSERDA to build a revenue support mechanism, a prequalification process, a competitive open-book negotiation process and a procurement framework for it. The staff white paper was filed in Case 26-E-0335 the same day Governor Kathy Hochul announced that NYSERDA and the department had completed the state's Advanced Nuclear Master Plan, unveiled at the state's third Nuclear Summit in Rochester.
The 8.4 GW is addition as much as ambition: New York's existing 3.4 GW of nuclear, the 4 GW pathway the governor directed the department to pursue in January 2026, and the plant of at least 1 GW she told the New York Power Authority to develop in June 2025. The commission still has to act. The master plan says the white paper will be open to further public comments, and neither document gives a date for a decision.
Who pays, and when
The white paper answers the question our report on NYPA's ten qualified developers left open on November 14. Ratepayers would pay mainly for results: staff wants their commitments limited to performance-based revenue support, on the Clean Energy Standard principle that support is "paid only once a project has been completed and is delivering energy and system benefits." That does not mean the payments "would necessarily be fully divorced from certain development and construction risks," staff adds, and it wants the standard's existing flexibility for inflation and supply chain cost changes considered during implementation. Staff recommends that the commission have it and NYSERDA design the revenue program so it can include state equity, "a State role in limited cost overrun risk sharing," and support before the final investment decision, such as grants, loans or credit enhancements.
Some of those pieces sit outside the commission's reach. Staff finds the full package "cannot be borne solely by ratepayers," and each piece needs money identified first; a cost overrun guarantee, the options paper noted, needs a funding source in place "even if it is never drawn upon." Parts may require legislative or executive action through the state budget. The June options paper by department staff and NYSERDA put the public cost of supporting 5 GW at about $15.4 billion to $23.9 billion over the plants' first 25 years of operation, depending on the pace of development and selected technologies, in present value for a greenfield site under base case assumptions; combining interventions could cut that range by up to 29%, and brownfield sites could cost up to 19% less.
Washington could carry most of the capital. Debt provided or facilitated by the Department of Energy's Office of Energy Dominance Financing and the Federal Financing Bank may cover up to 80% of the overnight capital cost of initial projects, the options paper noted, leaving equity of at least 20%, about $2 billion for a GW-scale project. Staff agrees that a sole state stake is not viable.
A data center buying a plant's output should lower what everyone else pays, in staff's view: it proposes that such third-party offtake deals bring support that "demonstrably and meaningfully" reduces the cost to other ratepayers, and be limited so the plants still serve statewide resource adequacy. Ratepayer support will likely be required regardless, staff says. It declines to recommend a cap on credit-style support such as the options paper's Advanced Nuclear Zero Emission Credits, since the commission has not capped support that way elsewhere in the Clean Energy Standard, but wants the idea kept under consideration during implementation.
Negotiated, not bid
Staff steers away from a conventional request for proposals. Where the state might share overrun risk, a competition "focused primarily on lowest bid price could create an incentive for proposals to be priced unrealistically, especially in a developing market in which cost projections are difficult to verify." It recommends competitive open-book negotiation with several parties in parallel. Eligibility would be narrow: new advanced nuclear only, with no support for uprates or life extensions at existing plants; at least 25 MW per reactor and 250 MW per project; and sites in NYISO Zones A through F, north and west of the lower Hudson Valley, with out-of-state projects possibly eligible if their power is physically delivered to New York.
NYPA's qualification round goes first, and staff expects to learn from it. It anticipates that experiences and findings from NYPA's process "will inform the design" of the state's prequalification process, and that benchmarks from its project could shape how risk is shared. Prequalification would open only after the commission approves an implementation plan, and any negotiated project would come back for approval.
Georgia's Vogtle runs through the paper from both directions. Commenters cite its overruns as the outcome to avoid, while the paper's account of the options paper notes that the Westinghouse AP1000 is the only design with a fully completed US project, which lowers its overrun risk relative to even the more mature small modular reactors. Staff calls it premature to settle on a pipeline or sequencing strategy.
On transmission, staff does not predefine lines. It expects future cycles of the Coordinated Grid Planning Process to model 5 GW of new nuclear and identify the resource and transmission investments needed. That planning process's modeling found that 5 GW of new nuclear could cut the need to overbuild renewables by around 20 GW and eliminate the need for 3 GW of transmission investments. NYPA's September comments had pointed to the public policy transmission process for moving upstate nuclear power downstate.
The master plan
The master plan's 30 points rest on 12 studies, per the governor's office. On siting, it would identify communities interested in hosting reactors and help them and partnering developers evaluate sites such as fossil brownfields, including by co-funding early site permits or site characterization, the on-site work for an NRC application that the plan says could cost $8 million to $13 million once a site is chosen. NYSERDA will hold a webinar on the plan on January 13, 2027.
The Army has already picked both a New York site and a reactor. Fort Drum was selected in August 2026 to host a Westinghouse eVinci microreactor of up to 20 MW, which the plan calls the first new reactor on New York soil in nearly 40 years. It sits well under the 250 MW floor staff proposes for state support. At Nine Mile Point, the plan cites Department of Energy and state co-funding for Constellation Energy's application for an early site permit for advanced reactors, a federal step that settles a location's key regulatory questions before a reactor design is chosen. NYPA, per the governor's office, has heard from eight communities interested in hosting its plant; our advanced reactor tracker follows the national field.
Sources
Primary
- Case 26-E-0335, DPS Staff Nuclear Reliability Backbone White Paper · New York State Department of Public Service
- Master Plan for Responsible Advanced Nuclear Development in New York · NYSERDA and New York State Department of Public Service
Supporting
- Comments of the New York Power Authority, Case 26-E-0335 · New York Power Authority (filed with the New York State Public Service Commission)
- Governor Hochul Announces Completion of Comprehensive Advanced Nuclear Master Plan · Office of the Governor of New York
Copies of cited sources are retained where available. If a link no longer resolves, request a copy at contact@theduckcurve.com.